A Cold Night for Crying — Story, Setting & Ideas
Edition facts
The catalog record for A Cold Night for Crying — Story, Setting & Ideas provides practical reading context through 7,961 words, 35 min estimated reading time, and 1 detected text section.
The text analysis averages about 13.6 words per sentence, while the detected sections provide another way to judge how the source is divided.
Project Gutenberg metadata also associates the work with “Science fiction,” connecting these edition facts with the source record’s subject description.
Calculated from edition completeness, EPUB availability, text structure and catalogue metadata. Not a user rating.
How this score is calculated
- Description quality20 pts
- Title & short description10 pts
- Source metadata20 pts
- Text length15 pts
- Chapters / structure15 pts
- EPUB file integrity20 pts
Total of 100 points, scaled to a 2.5-5.0 range. Editions with an empty description or a missing EPUB file are not scored.
Read the Text
There were neighbors, friends, brothers, even wives, there were the obvious quislings you shunned and the less obvious ones you didn't suspect until it was too late. One thing you never did was listen to the short-wave radio so defiantly its crackling could be heard not merely on the other side of the door but all the way out on the landing. The punishment was death.
Mr. Friedlander paused in front of his own door, where the odor of strong yellow turnips assailed his nostrils. It was so unsatisfyingly familiar, he almost gagged. The new generation hardly remembered the delightful old foods, but if Mr. Friedlander shut his eyes and thought, he could clearly smell steak and roast chicken and broiled lobster swimming in butter and a dry red wine to wash everything down slowly, so slowly he could taste every tiny morsel.
He pushed open the door and began to shrug off his worn coat. "I'm home," he said to the scabby walls, the gas range which had been converted to wood when the Karadi suspended all public utilities, to the bubbling pot which exuded the turnip smell, to the drab sofa, the two wooden chairs, the table he had constructed from two old saw horses and the planking he had found long ago after the Fourteenth Street Bomb.
From the small bedroom, he heard sobbing.
Mrs. Friedlander blinked red-rimmed eyes at him and squeezed his hand, wringing it as if it had been a wet rag. She was forty-four years old, six years younger than Mr. Friedlander, with a face which once had been comely but now was lined, gaunt and big-pored. She was even thinner than Mr. Friedlander, but looked shapeless in her thick woolen sweater and the baggy work trousers he had stolen from the quartermaster store of the plant where he worked.
"Try to tell me, Martha," he said. "It's good to talk."
She looked at him mutely, opening her mouth to talk but swallowing instead.
"You tell me, Martha. There now."
She managed to get the words out. "It's Freddie."
Mr. Friedlander placed a tired arm about her shoulder. The feeling had started in the pit of his stomach, like when their son George had died of pneumonia two years ago this month. The Karadi had outlawed all wonder drugs, all hospitals, all medical schools. Helpless, they had watched George die, his big child eyes not understanding, asking for help. Mr. Friedlander always wondered if he had died hating them.
"People die and you see them. You know," Mrs. Friedlander said. "They are sick and you can't do anything but try to nurse them, anyway. Or the big Karadi cars run them down and you see the broken body. You see them. Alive. Then dead. It's hard, so hard you want to stop living too, but there's God and God shows you they are dead and you have the memories, all the sweet ones. You know they're dead because you see them dying. You can forget. In time, you forget. You have to forget because otherwise you don't want to live, but you ... hold me. Hold me tight."
Mr. Friedlander patted her hair awkwardly. The Karadi not only condoned but encouraged displays of simple emotion and for that reason Mr. Friedlander tried to avoid them. "What are you trying to tell me?" he asked.
"Freddie. Freddie. His plane was shot down over the mountains, they told me. Freddie is dead. Freddie."
Mr. Friedlander stopped patting his wife's hair, stopped stroking the tangles into a smooth glossiness. He bent down and carefully unbuckled his torn overshoes, placing them carefully in a corner of the room. Then he walked to the window and stared out at the snow sparkling in wind-blown puffs under the street lamp which remained only because the Karadi liked to drive their confiscated autos at night. "What are you saying?" he asked his wife.
"Just because they tell us Freddie is dead--"
"Stop it. Don't say that."
"Freddie is dead. Because they tell us, that's no reason to believe. How can we believe? We saw Freddie alive, but now they tell us Freddie is dead. Far away, two thousand miles. Over the mountains. Did we see him die? He's dead. Oh, he's dead. But we'll never learn to live with it. Don't you see? How can we believe? How can we know? We saw him alive. Now he's dead."
Freddie was flying a Karadi plane against the last strongholds of free man in the Rocky Mountains. Not because Freddie had wanted to pilot the dart-swift craft particularly, but because they had made him. The Karadi announced their own human losses readily, almost as if they took great pleasure in the impressive figures. "They told you this?" Mr. Friedlander asked.
The story opens with snow as both a physical and symbolic presence: it 'sifted silently down,' mantling streets and burying the scars of a ruined city. Mr. Friedlander trudges home, his breath conjuring fantasies of cigars, steam radiators, and ocean liners—each a fleeting escape from the Karadi occupation. The snow, the cold, and the breath are not mere atmosphere; they become the medium through which the protagonist’s inner life is measured against the oppressive reality of rationing, surveillance, and the constant demand to believe what the occupiers dictate.
Breath as Escape and Evidence
Mr. Friedlander’s breath is a recurring motif: he ‘conjured fantasies from the white, multi-shaped exhalations of his breath.’ Each shape—cigar smoke, radiator steam, ship’s funnel—represents a lost comfort or freedom. The breath is also a marker of his physical state: he is cold, wet, and numb, yet his imagination remains active. Later, when he argues with his wife, the breath is absent; the fantasies have collapsed into the need for certainty. The story uses this simple bodily function to chart the shift from imaginative resistance to the rigid binary thinking the Karadi enforce.
The Elevator Shaft as a Measure of Loss
On each landing of his tenement, Mr. Friedlander pauses to look at the unused elevator shaft ‘with longing and resentment.’ The shaft is a vertical scar in the building, a reminder of a convenience the Karadi have denied. It also functions as a structural echo of the city’s ruined buildings: ‘the scars and stumps of buildings that remained.’ The elevator shaft is never used, never repaired—it stands as a silent monument to a world that has been stripped of its ordinary functions. The repetition of this pause at each landing reinforces the grinding routine of deprivation.
The Short-Wave Radio and the Risk of Hope
When Mr. Friedlander hears the crackling of a short-wave radio from a neighbor’s apartment, the sound is immediately dangerous: ‘The punishment was death.’ Yet the radio becomes the source of a rumor that Freddie, a young man believed dead, may be alive with barbarian fighters. Mr. Davidson, the radio’s owner, orchestrates a mock funeral to conceal the celebration. The radio is a device that splits the community: it offers hope, but also suspicion. Mr. Friedlander’s internal debate—whether to believe the radio or the Karadi’s official story—mirrors the story’s central tension between doubt and the comfort of certainty.
Snow as a Blanket and a Trap
The snow is described as ‘clouds of white confetti’ and later as frosting the window pane, giving a ‘ghostlike quality’ to the street. It covers the city’s wounds but also isolates the inhabitants. Mr. Friedlander’s journey home is a series of encounters with snow: it fills his overshoes, it obscures tire tracks, it muffles sound. The snow is both beautiful and treacherous—it hides the evidence of Karadi movements while making every step a struggle. In the final scene, the frosted window separates Mr. Friedlander from the outside world, trapping him in his own doubt.
Readers should attend to the way the story moves between interior monologue and dialogue, and how the physical environment—snow, breath, elevator shafts—mirrors the psychological landscape. The excerpts do not reveal the story’s resolution, but the pattern of doubt and belief is established early. Pay attention to the moments when Mr. Friedlander’s breath-fantasies return or disappear; they may signal shifts in his will to resist.
I keep returning to that frigid city, where every breath becomes a dream of somewhere warmer. Somehow, when that story sits beside Time In the Round — A Reader’s Guide, the elevator shafts start to feel like clock hands, measuring how we escape our own hours. A quiet agreement between them, I think, about the pause before resistance.
There are no reviews for this eBook.
Your personal reading reflection
Build a private reading journal entry for this title.